[BIP-216] Add permissions for Batch Relayer V5 (second attempt)
Payload PR - BIP-216
Background on repeat governance
BIP-214 was approved by governance, but upon review, which occurred after the snapshot, was found to specify the old V4 version of the relayer in both the BIP text and the payloads. The problem resulted the fact that there are many batch relayers with the same contract name. The script used found the most recent address of a given contract by looking through a reverse lookup table in the monorepo that was not up-to-date. The BIP-214 text specified the BalancerRelayer as the target to receive permissions, but did not include details about which deployment was listed.
The script that generates these BIPs has been updated to allow for targets to be specified as task/deployment (specified a specific version) and to print that information back out in the tables. The revised script was used to regenerate the BIP output and payloads defined below.
Background on the change
A new version of the primary relayer, BatchRelayer 5.0 deployed by task 20230314-batch-relayer-v5. Deployment of the fifth BalancerRelayer using BatchRelayerLibrary, for combining multiple operations (swaps, joins, etc.) in a single transaction.
As described in the payload json, the authorizer will be called to grant the roles as described.
The change can be reviewed by the below by comparing the results_deployment_sorted.md file to the source of truth, which should match the order found in the source of truth for actionIds on the balancer-v2-monorepo.
Target addresses can be verified by checking the outputs of the v5 Vault deployments here
For record, the contents of results_address_sorted.md are printed here:
| deployment | chain | function | role | target | target_address |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20210418-vault | arbitrum | batchSwap(uint8,(bytes32,uint256,uint256,uint256,bytes)[],address[],(address,bool,address,bool),int256[],uint256) | 0x1282ab709b2b70070f829c46bc36f76b32ad4989fecb2fcb09a1b3ce00bbfc30 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0x598ce0f1ab64B27256759ef99d883EE51138b9bd |
| 20210418-vault | arbitrum | exitPool(bytes32,address,address,(address[],uint256[],bytes,bool)) | 0xc149e88b59429ded7f601ab52ecd62331cac006ae07c16543439ed138dcb8d34 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0x598ce0f1ab64B27256759ef99d883EE51138b9bd |
| 20210418-vault | arbitrum | joinPool(bytes32,address,address,(address[],uint256[],bytes,bool)) | 0x78ad1b68d148c070372f8643c4648efbb63c6a8a338f3c24714868e791367653 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0x598ce0f1ab64B27256759ef99d883EE51138b9bd |
| 20210418-vault | arbitrum | manageUserBalance((uint8,address,uint256,address,address)[]) | 0xeba777d811cd36c06d540d7ff2ed18ed042fd67bbf7c9afcf88c818c7ee6b498 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0x598ce0f1ab64B27256759ef99d883EE51138b9bd |
| 20210418-vault | arbitrum | setRelayerApproval(address,address,bool) | 0x0014a06d322ff07fcc02b12f93eb77bb76e28cdee4fc0670b9dec98d24bbfec8 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0x598ce0f1ab64B27256759ef99d883EE51138b9bd |
| 20210418-vault | arbitrum | swap((bytes32,uint8,address,address,uint256,bytes),(address,bool,address,bool),uint256,uint256) | 0x7b8a1d293670124924a0f532213753b89db10bde737249d4540e9a03657d1aff | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0x598ce0f1ab64B27256759ef99d883EE51138b9bd |
| 20210418-vault | gnosis | batchSwap(uint8,(bytes32,uint256,uint256,uint256,bytes)[],address[],(address,bool,address,bool),int256[],uint256) | 0x1282ab709b2b70070f829c46bc36f76b32ad4989fecb2fcb09a1b3ce00bbfc30 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0x3536fD480CA495Ac91E698A703248A8915c137a3 |
| 20210418-vault | gnosis | exitPool(bytes32,address,address,(address[],uint256[],bytes,bool)) | 0xc149e88b59429ded7f601ab52ecd62331cac006ae07c16543439ed138dcb8d34 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0x3536fD480CA495Ac91E698A703248A8915c137a3 |
| 20210418-vault | gnosis | joinPool(bytes32,address,address,(address[],uint256[],bytes,bool)) | 0x78ad1b68d148c070372f8643c4648efbb63c6a8a338f3c24714868e791367653 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0x3536fD480CA495Ac91E698A703248A8915c137a3 |
| 20210418-vault | gnosis | manageUserBalance((uint8,address,uint256,address,address)[]) | 0xeba777d811cd36c06d540d7ff2ed18ed042fd67bbf7c9afcf88c818c7ee6b498 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0x3536fD480CA495Ac91E698A703248A8915c137a3 |
| 20210418-vault | gnosis | setRelayerApproval(address,address,bool) | 0x0014a06d322ff07fcc02b12f93eb77bb76e28cdee4fc0670b9dec98d24bbfec8 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0x3536fD480CA495Ac91E698A703248A8915c137a3 |
| 20210418-vault | gnosis | swap((bytes32,uint8,address,address,uint256,bytes),(address,bool,address,bool),uint256,uint256) | 0x7b8a1d293670124924a0f532213753b89db10bde737249d4540e9a03657d1aff | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0x3536fD480CA495Ac91E698A703248A8915c137a3 |
| 20210418-vault | mainnet | batchSwap(uint8,(bytes32,uint256,uint256,uint256,bytes)[],address[],(address,bool,address,bool),int256[],uint256) | 0x1282ab709b2b70070f829c46bc36f76b32ad4989fecb2fcb09a1b3ce00bbfc30 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0xfeA793Aa415061C483D2390414275AD314B3F621 |
| 20210418-vault | mainnet | exitPool(bytes32,address,address,(address[],uint256[],bytes,bool)) | 0xc149e88b59429ded7f601ab52ecd62331cac006ae07c16543439ed138dcb8d34 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0xfeA793Aa415061C483D2390414275AD314B3F621 |
| 20210418-vault | mainnet | joinPool(bytes32,address,address,(address[],uint256[],bytes,bool)) | 0x78ad1b68d148c070372f8643c4648efbb63c6a8a338f3c24714868e791367653 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0xfeA793Aa415061C483D2390414275AD314B3F621 |
| 20210418-vault | mainnet | manageUserBalance((uint8,address,uint256,address,address)[]) | 0xeba777d811cd36c06d540d7ff2ed18ed042fd67bbf7c9afcf88c818c7ee6b498 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0xfeA793Aa415061C483D2390414275AD314B3F621 |
| 20210418-vault | mainnet | setRelayerApproval(address,address,bool) | 0x0014a06d322ff07fcc02b12f93eb77bb76e28cdee4fc0670b9dec98d24bbfec8 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0xfeA793Aa415061C483D2390414275AD314B3F621 |
| 20210418-vault | mainnet | swap((bytes32,uint8,address,address,uint256,bytes),(address,bool,address,bool),uint256,uint256) | 0x7b8a1d293670124924a0f532213753b89db10bde737249d4540e9a03657d1aff | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0xfeA793Aa415061C483D2390414275AD314B3F621 |
| 20210418-vault | optimism | batchSwap(uint8,(bytes32,uint256,uint256,uint256,bytes)[],address[],(address,bool,address,bool),int256[],uint256) | 0x1282ab709b2b70070f829c46bc36f76b32ad4989fecb2fcb09a1b3ce00bbfc30 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0x03F1ab8b19bcE21EB06C364aEc9e40322572a1e9 |
| 20210418-vault | optimism | exitPool(bytes32,address,address,(address[],uint256[],bytes,bool)) | 0xc149e88b59429ded7f601ab52ecd62331cac006ae07c16543439ed138dcb8d34 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0x03F1ab8b19bcE21EB06C364aEc9e40322572a1e9 |
| 20210418-vault | optimism | joinPool(bytes32,address,address,(address[],uint256[],bytes,bool)) | 0x78ad1b68d148c070372f8643c4648efbb63c6a8a338f3c24714868e791367653 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0x03F1ab8b19bcE21EB06C364aEc9e40322572a1e9 |
| 20210418-vault | optimism | manageUserBalance((uint8,address,uint256,address,address)[]) | 0xeba777d811cd36c06d540d7ff2ed18ed042fd67bbf7c9afcf88c818c7ee6b498 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0x03F1ab8b19bcE21EB06C364aEc9e40322572a1e9 |
| 20210418-vault | optimism | setRelayerApproval(address,address,bool) | 0x0014a06d322ff07fcc02b12f93eb77bb76e28cdee4fc0670b9dec98d24bbfec8 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0x03F1ab8b19bcE21EB06C364aEc9e40322572a1e9 |
| 20210418-vault | optimism | swap((bytes32,uint8,address,address,uint256,bytes),(address,bool,address,bool),uint256,uint256) | 0x7b8a1d293670124924a0f532213753b89db10bde737249d4540e9a03657d1aff | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0x03F1ab8b19bcE21EB06C364aEc9e40322572a1e9 |
| 20210418-vault | polygon | batchSwap(uint8,(bytes32,uint256,uint256,uint256,bytes)[],address[],(address,bool,address,bool),int256[],uint256) | 0x1282ab709b2b70070f829c46bc36f76b32ad4989fecb2fcb09a1b3ce00bbfc30 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0xd18d5D377eb23362e54Fa496597d7E962d56C554 |
| 20210418-vault | polygon | exitPool(bytes32,address,address,(address[],uint256[],bytes,bool)) | 0xc149e88b59429ded7f601ab52ecd62331cac006ae07c16543439ed138dcb8d34 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0xd18d5D377eb23362e54Fa496597d7E962d56C554 |
| 20210418-vault | polygon | joinPool(bytes32,address,address,(address[],uint256[],bytes,bool)) | 0x78ad1b68d148c070372f8643c4648efbb63c6a8a338f3c24714868e791367653 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0xd18d5D377eb23362e54Fa496597d7E962d56C554 |
| 20210418-vault | polygon | manageUserBalance((uint8,address,uint256,address,address)[]) | 0xeba777d811cd36c06d540d7ff2ed18ed042fd67bbf7c9afcf88c818c7ee6b498 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0xd18d5D377eb23362e54Fa496597d7E962d56C554 |
| 20210418-vault | polygon | setRelayerApproval(address,address,bool) | 0x0014a06d322ff07fcc02b12f93eb77bb76e28cdee4fc0670b9dec98d24bbfec8 | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0xd18d5D377eb23362e54Fa496597d7E962d56C554 |
| 20210418-vault | polygon | swap((bytes32,uint8,address,address,uint256,bytes),(address,bool,address,bool),uint256,uint256) | 0x7b8a1d293670124924a0f532213753b89db10bde737249d4540e9a03657d1aff | 20230314-batch-relayer-v5/BalancerRelayer | 0xd18d5D377eb23362e54Fa496597d7E962d56C554 |
Risk Assessment
This BIP is routine operation for provisioning a contract deployment/Batch Relayer. Users must also approve BatchRelayers before they have access. More details can be found in the Special Vault Permissions Context doc.
References
Directory of Addresses used by script which generated the table and multsig payloads
The full proposal with the English specification can be read on the forum. The snapshot proposal has been shortened to adhere to the 14'400 character limit
Off-Chain Vote
Yes, let's do it
4.28M veBAL100%
No, this is not the way
0.11 veBAL0%
Abstain
0.56 veBAL0%
Quorum:214%
Timeline
Mar 22, 2023Proposal created
Mar 23, 2023Proposal vote started
Mar 27, 2023Proposal vote ended
Feb 16, 2026Proposal updated