• © Goverland Inc. 2026
  • v1.0.1
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
Moons GovernanceMoons Governanceby0xe72BE6b57F41022a2707A8663f5e5b4C48E3F4f7Max (CryptoMaximalist)

CCIP-088 - Remove only the complicated and obsolete karma calculations, keep only the urgent and essential CCIPs we need from day 1

Voting ended over 1 year agoSucceeded

There is currently a vote to remove all or keep all past CCIPs related to Moon distribution. Many may become obsolete or need to be re-worked if we use a new distribution system.

However, not all of those CCIPs are gonna be obsolete, and a few are actually important to have from day 1.

Remove all the complicated KM related proposal, karma calculations, obsolete proposals, and the ones that could use a new proposal later.

Keep the essential and more urgent ones that we will need from day 1, and the ones that most people expect to return.

Keep:

CCIP-009 - Make mod's distinguished posts ineligible for moons

CCIP-006 - 5% Bonus MOONs for anyone who votes on governance polls

CCIP-014 - Incentivize Voting in Multiple Polls

CCIP-011 - Disqualify removed content from moon rewards.

CCIP-015 - Disincentive Extreme Moon Farming Spam

CCIP-024 - Tag in title to opt-out of Moons

Remove (make a new proposal later if needs be):

CCIP-001 - MOON Proposal: Double Comment Karma

CCIP-003 - Limit post karma to 1k and limit comment karma to 1k per comment

CCIP-004 -10% karma on Media and Comedy posts.

CCIP-029 - Dynamic karma cap

CCIP-030 - Retention Rate Multiplier

CCIP-031 - Remove vaultless users below 10 karma from the snapshot and distribution

CCIP-038 - Reduce Karma for Link Post from 1x to 0.5x

CCIP-041 - Increase Karma Multiplier for SERIOUS posts from 1x to 2x

CCIP-044 - 2x Karma for comments under Serious Posts

CCIP-049 - Exclude Dead Address From Moons

Why keep those 6 proposals?

Voting bonus-I think most people will expect to keep their governance voting bonus, for their reward for participating in governance. Governance which is at the core of the whole purpose of Moons.

Mod stickied post- I think even the mod would agree it's more fair to disqualify their stickied post from earning them moons.

Disqualified content- I think it's safe to say that spammers, rule breakers, off topic content, and people just trying to sneak in off topic or disqualified clickbait while the mods aren't looking, and any content not belonging, shouldn't get rewarded just because mods had their hands full for an hour. Blocked content like coin limit, isn't affected by this.

Extreme spamming- I think it's also safe to say that extreme spamming should be disincentivized. And we want that loophole unavailable from day 1.

[No moon] tag in title- It's more about having no reason to remove this option. We should still allow people to have that choice and option, if they want to opt out.

Off-Chain Vote

Implement this change
3.17M MOON83.2%
No change
640.55K MOON16.8%
Download mobile app to vote

Discussion

Moons GovernanceCCIP-088 - Remove only the complicated and obsolete karma calculations, keep only the urgent and essential CCIPs we need from day 1

Timeline

May 28, 2024Proposal created
May 28, 2024Proposal vote started
Jun 04, 2024Proposal vote ended
Dec 14, 2025Proposal updated