KIP-23: Discretionary Investment Limit

This is an apparent consensus vote, open to ROOK and xROOK token holders.

• Vote 'No objection' if you agree with the proposal.
• Vote 'Object' if you disagree with the proposal. If voting ‘Object’ to the proposal, you are encouraged to voice your reasoning on the Rook Forum. Objections that are backed by a strong argument may potentially hold more weight than a simple objection vote.

Results

KIPs that receive > 50% ‘No Objection’ votes do not automatically pass. On completion of the vote, ‘Object’ votes will be analyzed and discussed by the Rook team and community. If a significant number of objections occur, the vote will either be marked as ‘Failed’ or enter a reconciliation phase. For more information, see the Rook Governance Beigepaper.

Proposal Full Text Links

The full text of KIP-23, including images, is available at: (link) KIP-23 on Github (link) KIP-23 on the governance forum

Proposal Summary

---

kip: 23
title: Establish a Discretionary Investment Limit
author: DaddyMatty <matt@rook.fi>
status: last-call
tags: none
created: 2022-4-25
replaced-by: none
replaces: none
dependency: KIP-12, KIP-21

Proposal

Empower Rook Labs to be able to make investments up to the lesser of $5M or 5% of the treasury’s notional value every 180 days.

Background

While DAO input and buy-in are imperative to the long-term success and sustainability of our financial position, certain opportunities present themselves that must be capitalized on quickly and in a non-public fashion. To ensure these opportunities are not lost due to poor execution or front running, Rook Labs must have some discretion to utilize funds without going through the governance process.

More specifically, this KIP proposes that Rook Labs be empowered to make investments up to the lesser of $5M or 5% of the treasury’s notional value every 180 days. Note: the limits around discretionary investments are cumulative in that the ROOK team would not be able to execute five separate $1M transactions to avoid going through governance.

To ensure proper due care and diligence was performed, the ROOK team must present their rationale to the DAO within 48 hours of executing the transaction(s). Furthermore, Rook Labs must present that the investment was approved by the CEO and CTO. Potential Applications:

There are numerous reasons that having a discretionary investment limit could be highly accretive for the DAO and allow us to maximize our investment performance over the near and long term. The following items below represent the most likely applications of this limit:

• Merger and Acquisitions: In most, if not all, M&A transactions there is often a high level of confidentiality that must be maintained by both sides in order to ensure that the due diligence and negotiation process is fair and effective. If the other party in a M&A opportunity knows that Rook DAO cannot maintain a high level of confidentiality, we may be excluded from certain opportunities. Even if we are not excluded on the front end from these opportunities, our ability to execute upon them may be limited due to external forces frontrunning our investment or creating a bidding war. It is therefore imperative that we signal to other interested parties that we have the ability to have discussions without these risks.

• Securing Optimal Investment Prices: Because governance is transparent and relatively slow moving, both internal and external parties have the benefit of knowing the DAO’s intentions before actions can be taken. This creates a situation where the DAO can get front run on potential investment opportunities or lose out on the opportunities all together. By allowing the DAO to take advantage of these opportunities without signalling our intent to the rest of the ecosystem, we can capture value in a nimble way while optimizing our investment basis.

• Black Swan Rebalancing: In the event of unexpected major black-swan events, the DAO’s treasury must have the ability to be nimble in rebalancing its holdings to protect from significant declines. By having the ability to reposition our assets into more stable or liquid assets, we can not only protect the value that we have created, but also take advantage of lower market prices when there may be a better buying opportunity.

Recourse

In the event that the community comes to consensus that a discretionary investment made was inappropriate, they could take any of the following actions:

• Unwind the action through a formal KIP
• Ability to call an “all hands on deck” community call with Rook Labs team and individuals involved in the investment decision to discuss next steps.
• Remove applicable team members from their positions

Specification

Empower Rook Labs to be able to make investments up to the lesser of $5M or 5% of the treasury’s notional value every 360 days.